37 helpful comments later

After thinking through the 37 helpful comments posted to my post about comment policy, I’ve decided to start slowly as proposed. That means:

I have adopted a policy of deleting personal attacks on others. That means any comment that is directed against someone other than me, which is uncivil and attacking something other than the substance of what that person has written as a comment on my blog will be removed if (1) a request is made by anyone to [email protected], and (2) the volunteer I’ve selected agrees the policy has been violated.

I like some of the other suggestions, including incorporating the slashdot system. As things develop, I may move to something more.

Thanks to all for the help.

This entry was posted in eye. Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to 37 helpful comments later

  1. I’ve often wondered if commenting systems shouldn’t have a good/shunt/junk ternary set of choices. Good posts, unmolested or moderated to appear, show up. Junk posts made by robots are noted for future Bayesian improvement, and deleted.

    But posts that are hateful, indecent, or otherwise improper, and made by human beings, would be shifted into a different area in which those comments would be available to anyone who had the academic interest to read. While you cannot be called a censor (given you don’t control all fora), it would be an interesting experiment. On my various blogs and lists, I have always been a strong moderator, so I’ve never tried this particular idea.

    Back in 1994 to 1996, when I ran the Internet Marketing Discussion List, early on was given grief about my moderation policies. I said to the grief causers, hey, start your own list, and I’ll promote it on my list. If people prefer an unmoderated, unfettered discussion, I will lose subscribers, you will gain them. Of course, the competing list wound up with a few hundred people, discussion went out of control, and spammers took over. I had 7,000 subscribers by the time I shut the list down.

  2. Peter says:


    I absolute agree to delete unacceptable comments. It’s your blog and if there are “stupid” comments, it look like that you don’t care about it.
    I often read the newspaper on internet and under the article is always discusion. But most of time the 30% comments are just personal attack, who cares about that? I would like to read the discusion not personal feeling or that someone have a bad mood.


  3. Actually no matter if someone doesn’t know afterward its up to other viewers that they will assist, so here it takes place.

Leave a Reply