Monthly Archives: May 2003

REGISTERing a difference

So the Register has a piece about my post yesterday, attacking Dr. Pangloss and his predictions that the Internet will save us all from the dangers of media concentration. Midway through, Andrew Orlowski writes, “‘The Internet is dying,’ he writes.” Actually, that’s not quite what I wrote, the quotes not withstanding. What I wrote was: “‘The Internet’ that is to be the savior is a dying breed.” That is, the “end-to-end Internet,” where the edge holds the intelligence, is a dying breed. Something called “the Internet” will be with us forever, so in that sense, “the Internet” will never die. But the end-to-end internet (the only internet that really matters to any important issue) is a more fragile beast. Continue reading

Posted in free culture | 4 Comments

we need your help

About a month ago, I started sounding optimistic about getting a bill introduced into Congress to help right the wrong of the Sonny Bono Copyright Term Extension Act. I was optimistic because we had found a congressperson who was willing to introduce the bill. But after pressure from lobbyists, that is no longer clear. And so we need help to counter that pressure, and to find a sponsor.

The idea is a simple one: Fifty years after a work has been published, the copyright owner must pay a $1 maintanence fee. If the copyright owner pays the fee, then the copyright continues. If the owner fails to pay the fee, the work passes into the public domain. Based on historical precedent, we expect 98% of copyrighted works would pass into the public domain after just 50 years. They could keep Mickey for as long as Congress lets them. But we would get a public domain.

The need for even this tiny compromise is becoming clearer each day. Stanford’s library, for example, has announced a digitization project to digitize books. They have technology that can scan 1,000 pages an hour. They are chafing for the opportunity to scan books that are no longer commercially available, but that under current law remain under copyright. If this proposal passed, 98% of books just 50 years old could be scanned and posted for free on the Internet.

Stanford is not alone. This has long been a passion of Brewster Kahle and his Internet Archive, as well as many others. Yet because of current copyright regulation, these projects — that would lower the cost of libraries dramatically, and spread knowledge broadly — cannot go forward. The costs of clearing the rights to makes these works available is extraordinarily high.

Yet the lobbyists are fighting even this tiny compromise. The public domain is competition for them. They will fight this competition. And so long as they have the lobbyists, and the rest of the world remains silent, they will win.

We need to your help to resist this now. At this stage, all that we need is one congressperson to introduce the proposal. Whether you call it the Copyright Term Deregulation Act, or the Public Domain Enhancement Act, doesn’t matter. What matters is finding a sponsor, so we can begin to show the world just how extreme this debate has become: They have already gotten a 20 year extension of all copyrights just so 2% can benefit; and now they object to paying just $1 for that benefit, so that no one else might compete with them.

If you believe this is wrong, here are two things you can do: (1) Write your Representative and Senator, and ask them to be the first to introduce this statute; point them to the website http://eldred.cc, and ask them to respond. And even more importantly, (2) blog this request, so that others who think about these issues can get involved in the conversation.

I have given this movement as much as I can over the past four years, and I will not stop until we have reclaimed the public domain. Stay tuned for more litigation, and more ideas from Creative Commons. But please take these two steps now. Continue reading

Posted in eldred.cc | 15 Comments

a new featured commoner

There’s a very cool new featured commoner at the Creative Commons site. Continue reading

Posted in cc | Comments Off on a new featured commoner

MediaCon: Barger

Tom Barger has a nice story about changing his mind. If ideology didn’t govern in DC, perhaps it would do some good. Continue reading

Posted in free culture | 1 Comment

MediaCon: “but there’s the internet”

Of all the lines that Dr. Pangloss pesters me with (and you know who you are), the one that gets me the most goes something like this: “But there’s an internet now. Why do you worry about media concentration when there’s an internet?”

So there’s a million reasons why this is silly — despite the importance of blogs, etc. But the one that’s most relevant is this:

At the same time that media concentration restrictions are being removed, such that 3 companies will own everything, so too are neutrality restrictions for the network being eliminated, so that those same three companies — who will also control broadband access — are totally free to architect broadband however they wish. “The Internet” that is to be the savior is a dying breed. The end-to-end architecture that gave us its power will. in effect, be inverted. And so the games networks play to benefit their own will bleed to this space too.

And then Dr. Pangloss says, “but what about spectrum. Won’t unlicensed spectrum guarantee our freedom?” And it is true: Here at least there was some hope from this FCC. But the latest from DC is that a tiny chunk of new unlicensed spectrum will be released. And then after that, no more. Spectrum too will be sold — to the same companies, no doubt.

So then, Dr. Pangloss: When the content layer, the logical layer, and the physical layer are all effectively owned by a handful of companies, free of any requirements of neutrality or openness, what will you ask then? Continue reading

Posted in free culture | 7 Comments

MediaCon: Weinberger

David Weinberger has been contributing small and important pieces to our collective cluetrain of thought (ok, that was too cute, sorry). He’s got it right here. Continue reading

Posted in free culture | 2 Comments

MediaCon: Krugman brilliance

http://www.ucomics.com/cgi-bin/sendtoafriend/getpostcard.cgi?site_ref=ucomics&MsgID=aad64d79b576f874d86e31e563cad0ce Continue reading

Posted in free culture | 5 Comments

MediaCon: put best

This is a brilliant cartoon by Toles which captures this whole debate best. Continue reading

Posted in free culture | Comments Off on MediaCon: put best

MediaCon: Donna nails it

The link to link all things important. Continue reading

Posted in heroes | Comments Off on MediaCon: Donna nails it

MediaCon: criticism growning

There is growing criticism of the June 2 planned announcement at the FCC. MoveOn.org has joined the fight, as has BoingBoing, ReinRadar, and Aaron. Continue reading

Posted in free culture | 1 Comment